Skip to main content

Table 3 Summary of the included studies

From: A meta-analysis of the resuscitative effects of mechanical and manual chest compression in out-of-hospital cardiac arrest patients

Year

Author

Country

Type of medical device

Setting

CPC score

ROSC

Survival to admission

Survival to discharge

     

113/655:2/44

236/655:13/44

Not reported

117/655:5/44

1998

Edward T. Dickinson

USA

Thumper

Out of hospital

Not reported

Not reported

0/10:1/7

0/10:0/7

2006

Christer Axelsson

Sweden

Lucas

Out of hospital

Not reported

51/105:52/105

37/105:38/105

4/105:2/105

2006

Al Hallstrom

USA and Canada

Autopulse

Out of hospital

28/371:12/391

Not report

Not reported

37/373:23/394

2011

David Smekal

Sweden

Lucas

Out of hospital

Not reported

23/73:30/75

15/73:18/75

7/73:6/75

2012

Marcus Eng Hock Ong

Singapore

Autopulse

Out of hospital

2/459:13/552

103/459:195/552

6/459:18/552

2/459:13/552

2014

Lars Wik

Norway

Autopulse

Out of hospital

Not reported

689/2132:600/2099

Not reported

233/2132:196/2099

2014

Sten Rubertsson

Sweden, Netherlands, and UK

Lucas

Out of hospital

100/1289:108/1300

466/1289:460/1300

Not reported

118/1289:117/1300

2015

Sebastian Zeiner

Austria

Lucas and Autopulse

Out of hospital

113/655:19/239

236/655:82/239

Not reported

117/655:31/239

2015

Gavin D Perkins

UK

Lucas

Out of hospital

168/2815:77/1649

Not reported

193/2819:104/1652

Not reported

2015

Ching-Kuo Lin

Taiwan

Life-Stat 1008 Cardiopulmonary Resuscitator

Out of hospital

Not reported

51/188:72/216

33/188:48/216

Not reported

2016

David G. Buckler

USA

Not reported

Out of hospital

5976/63056:984/17625

20,493/63056:5023/17625

18,097/63056:4389/17625

7125/63056:1234/17625

2016

Chengjin Gao

China

Autopulse

Out of hospital

2/64: 5/69

15/64:31/69

Not reported

4/64:13/69

2017

Venkataraman Anantharaman

Singapore

Lucas

Out of hospital

Not reported

258/923:88/255

Not reported

27/923:13/255

2017

Kei Hayasida

Japan

Lucas and Autopulse

Out of hospital

Not reported

1561/5619:240/918

1019/5619:156/918

145/5619:23/918

2017

Bjarne Madsen Hardig

Sweden

Lucas

Out of hospital

89/383:92/374

222/383:218/374

Not reported

99:383 99:374